WhataHotel! is the luxury hotel division of Lorraine Travel, family-owned since 1948.All hotels · Plan with an advisor · 305.446.4433
What a Hotel

The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel vs The Fifth Avenue Hotel

New York · about 3.9 km apart

Which is better?

For most travellers, The Fifth Avenue Hotel edges it — it leads on value, dining and facilities. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is still the better pick if luxury pedigree matters most to you.

Choose The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel for

  • The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel carries the Rosewood name — one of the most prestigious flags in luxury hotels.

Choose The Fifth Avenue Hotel for

  • The Fifth Avenue Hotel typically starts from about $1,395 a night versus $1,850 at The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel.
  • The Fifth Avenue Hotel has 3 on-site restaurants and bars to 0 at The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel.
  • The Fifth Avenue Hotel adds fitness centre, parking and butler service.

Live prices for your dates

Real advisor rates, with complimentary perks included.

Add dates to see live rates

Head-to-head

  • Luxury pedigreeThe Carlyle, A Rosewood HotelThe Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel carries the Rosewood name — one of the most prestigious flags in luxury hotels.
  • ValueThe Fifth Avenue HotelThe Fifth Avenue Hotel typically starts from about $1,395 a night versus $1,850 at The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel.
  • Exclusive perksTieBoth come with a similar set of complimentary WhataHotel perks.
  • DiningThe Fifth Avenue HotelThe Fifth Avenue Hotel has 3 on-site restaurants and bars to 0 at The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel.
  • FacilitiesThe Fifth Avenue HotelThe Fifth Avenue Hotel adds fitness centre, parking and butler service.

Side by side

The Carlyle, A Rosewood HotelThe Fifth Avenue Hotel
BrandRosewoodIndependent
Star rating
Typical starting ratefrom $1,850 / nightfrom $1,395 / night
Exclusive perks
  • A Room Category Upgrade subject to availability at Check-In
  • Complimentary Continental Breakfast x 2 Daily at Carlyle
  • A $100 F & B Credit
  • Free WiFi
  • A Room Category Upgrade if Available at Check-In
  • Complimentary Full Breakfast for two Guests Daily
  • A $100 Hotel Credit
  • Free Wi-Fi
On-site dining—
  • *Cafe Carmellini*
  • *The Portrait Bar*
  • *In-room Dining*
Nearby—Bank of America · Central Park · Grand Central Station · Museum of Modern Art
Breakfast
Fitness centre
Parking
Butler service

Starting rates are indicative; live prices vary by date. Facilities are those listed by each hotel.

Frequently asked

Which is better, The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel or The Fifth Avenue Hotel?

For most travellers, The Fifth Avenue Hotel edges it — it leads on value, dining and facilities. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is still the better pick if luxury pedigree matters most to you.

Which is cheaper, The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel or The Fifth Avenue Hotel?

The Fifth Avenue Hotel is typically the more affordable of the two, starting from about $1,395 a night versus $1,850 at The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel. Rates change by date, so compare live prices for your exact stay.

What perks do you get at The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel and The Fifth Avenue Hotel?

Booking through WhataHotel adds complimentary advisor perks. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel: A Room Category Upgrade subject to availability at Check-In, Complimentary Continental Breakfast x 2 Daily at Carlyle and A $100 F & B Credit. The Fifth Avenue Hotel: A Room Category Upgrade if Available at Check-In, Complimentary Full Breakfast for two Guests Daily and A $100 Hotel Credit.

How far apart are The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel and The Fifth Avenue Hotel?

They're about 3.9 km apart in New York.

Which has better dining, The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel or The Fifth Avenue Hotel?

The Fifth Avenue Hotel has more on-site dining — 3 restaurants and bars versus 0.

More New York hotel comparisons