WhataHotel! is the luxury hotel division of Lorraine Travel, family-owned since 1948.All hotels · Plan with an advisor · 305.446.4433
What a Hotel

The Fifth Avenue Hotel vs The Peninsula New York

New York · about 2.1 km apart

Which is better?

For most travellers, The Peninsula New York edges it — it leads on luxury pedigree, dining and facilities. The Fifth Avenue Hotel is still the better pick if value matters most to you.

Choose The Fifth Avenue Hotel for

  • The Fifth Avenue Hotel typically starts from about $1,395 a night versus $2,145 at The Peninsula New York.

Choose The Peninsula New York for

  • The Peninsula New York carries the Peninsula name — one of the most prestigious flags in luxury hotels.
  • The Peninsula New York has 4 on-site restaurants and bars to 0 at The Fifth Avenue Hotel.
  • The Peninsula New York adds spa.

Live prices for your dates

Real advisor rates, with complimentary perks included.

Add dates to see live rates

Head-to-head

  • Luxury pedigreeThe Peninsula New YorkThe Peninsula New York carries the Peninsula name — one of the most prestigious flags in luxury hotels.
  • ValueThe Fifth Avenue HotelThe Fifth Avenue Hotel typically starts from about $1,395 a night versus $2,145 at The Peninsula New York.
  • Exclusive perksTieBoth come with a similar set of complimentary WhataHotel perks.
  • DiningThe Peninsula New YorkThe Peninsula New York has 4 on-site restaurants and bars to 0 at The Fifth Avenue Hotel.
  • FacilitiesThe Peninsula New YorkThe Peninsula New York adds spa.

Side by side

The Fifth Avenue HotelThe Peninsula New York
BrandIndependentPeninsula
Star rating
Typical starting ratefrom $1,395 / nightfrom $2,145 / night
Exclusive perks
  • A Room Category Upgrade if Available at Check-In
  • Complimentary Full Breakfast for two Guests Daily
  • A $100 Hotel Credit
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • A Room Upgrade at the Time on Booking is Already Included
  • Full Breakfast x 2 Daily
  • $100 F&B or Spa Credit
  • Free WiFi
On-site dining—
  • Clement
  • The Gotham Lounge
  • The Bar at Clement
  • Salon De Ning
Nearby—9-11 Tribute Center · American Museum of Natural History · Battery Park · Broadway Theaters
Breakfast
Spa

Starting rates are indicative; live prices vary by date. Facilities are those listed by each hotel.

Frequently asked

Which is better, The Fifth Avenue Hotel or The Peninsula New York?

For most travellers, The Peninsula New York edges it — it leads on luxury pedigree, dining and facilities. The Fifth Avenue Hotel is still the better pick if value matters most to you.

Which is cheaper, The Fifth Avenue Hotel or The Peninsula New York?

The Fifth Avenue Hotel is typically the more affordable of the two, starting from about $1,395 a night versus $2,145 at The Peninsula New York. Rates change by date, so compare live prices for your exact stay.

What perks do you get at The Fifth Avenue Hotel and The Peninsula New York?

Booking through WhataHotel adds complimentary advisor perks. The Fifth Avenue Hotel: A Room Category Upgrade if Available at Check-In, Complimentary Full Breakfast for two Guests Daily and A $100 Hotel Credit. The Peninsula New York: A Room Upgrade at the Time on Booking is Already Included, Full Breakfast x 2 Daily and $100 F&B or Spa Credit.

How far apart are The Fifth Avenue Hotel and The Peninsula New York?

They're about 2.1 km apart in New York.

Which has better dining, The Fifth Avenue Hotel or The Peninsula New York?

The Peninsula New York has more on-site dining — 4 restaurants and bars versus 0.

More New York hotel comparisons